| Financial services | Accounting and accounts reconstruction | Conducted an investigation into the accounting implications of a $1 billion duplicated automated payment batch by a large financial institution. The review included understanding the underlying accounting structure and processes, reviewing suspense accounts and customer impact and assessing the remediation processes in place to correct the duplication. | |
| Financial services | Accounting and accounts reconstruction | Completed an accounting reconstruction of loan balances and financial statements over a four year period for the private companies of a high net worth individual. The reconstruction was required by the client in response to ATO enquiries into historical tax returns. The reconstruction identified a number of errors in the previous accounting presentation and disclosure and resulted in a restatement of the financial statements for four financial years. | |
| Manufacturing | Accounting and accounts reconstruction | Performed a complex reconciliation of general ledger and sub ledger accounting data, requiring the interrogation and analysis of large volumes of data held in an SQL environment. | |
| Financial services | Accounting and accounts reconstruction | Investigated the non-disclosure of key balance sheet items by the National Bank of Tajikistan to the International Monetary Fund. Responsible for managing the team’s audit of the work undertaken by the bank to correct this non-disclosure, including understanding complex concealment of transactions and conducting interviews with senior bank officials. | |
| Media and Entertainment | Asset and funds tracing | Instructed by a legal firm acting on behalf of an investor to provide expert evidence related to the accounting for transactions in the financing of a stage production by Capital Finance Corporation, as compared with the prospectus for the project. | Independent expert witness |
| Financial services | Asset and funds tracing | On behalf of the Volcker Commission, was a senior member of the team in Switzerland engaged to determine the existence of dormant bank accounts and assets at a global Swiss financial institution which allegedly belonged to the victims of Nazi persecution. | |
| Retail | Asset and funds tracing | Led the forensic team analysing the payment of dividends around a complex group structure following the collapse of a large multi-services business. | |
| Financial services | Asset and funds tracing | Led the tracing of approximately $1 billion of dividend payments from numerous subsidiaries through to parent entities. The work was part of the defence to an investigation into a complex intra-company dividend arrangement within the context of a large taxation dispute. | |
| Financial services | Asset and funds tracing | Led an investigation into the ownership of vehicles in a vehicle leasing joint venture. | |
| Public sector | Business ethics | Facilitated business ethics training for a public sector client. | |
| Energy and resources | Business interruption | Acted as an expert in a dispute involving one of the world’s largest mining companies seeking damages of approximately $50 million following the failure of a significant piece of mining equipment. | Independent expert witness |
| Printing | Business interruption | Instructed by a legal firm on behalf of an insurer to respond to an independent expert accountants report quantifying the loss and damage allegedly suffered due to a fire in a printing business. | Independent expert witness |
| Insurance | Business interruption | Instructed by a legal firm on behalf of an insurer to respond to an independent expert accountants report quantifying the loss and damage allegedly suffered by a hospitality business following an interruption to the business caused by building works. | Independent expert witness |
| Public sector | Business interruption | Advised a government agency on loss of profit claims made against it by a hotel manager following disruption to the trading of one of its hotels due to business interrupting events. | Independent expert witness |
| Insurance | Business interruption | Prepared an expert accountants report on behalf of an international insurer exercising its rights under subrogation. The work included estimating loss of gross profits and increased costs of working arising from the destruction of the insured’s main production facility by fire. The forensic team worked alongside loss adjusters and lawyers reassessing amounts claimed under the original insurance policy and compiling revised claims for presentation to the Court. | Independent expert witness |
| Retail | Business interruption | Advised a European retailer of the economic loss it suffered following the closure of a major retail development due to ground subsidence. | Independent expert witness |
| Travel and leisure | Capture and analysis | Provided forensic technology assistance to a leisure company with respect to the production of electronic information to legal advisers based in the USA as a result of discovery orders, including the capture, analysis and preservation of a substantial amount of electronic evidence and the development of methodologies for data production. | |
| Insurance | Capture and analysis | Undertook the analysis, investigation and data warehousing of all electronic information and data captured as a result of the collapse of HIH Insurances Limited. In addition, developed an e-evidence solution to allow electronic records to be made available to all requesting parties. | |
| Pharmaceuticals | Capture and analysis | Project managed the forensic technology services provided to a pharmaceutical company in relation to an international dispute. The work involved the ongoing management and leadership of the electronic discovery process for a number of Asian countries. | |
| Media and Entertainment | Capture and analysis | Engaged to provide expert witness services by an Australian broadcasting corporation in relation to a broadcasting rights dispute. | |
| Transport | Capture and analysis | Undertook a computer based investigation on behalf of a New Zealand based transport company in relation to alleged breaches of fair trading practices. | |
| Regulatory | Capture and analysis | Assisted a Commonwealth agency with the execution of court orders to identify and capture electronic evidence from an internet service provider. Was also appointed as joint expert to conduct further examination of the data captured. | |
| Manufacturing | Capture and analysis | Project managed the forensic technology team engaged by the administrators of ION Limited to identify, capture and analyse data captured from a variety of sources including live systems, computers and backup tapes. | |
| Law enforcement | Capture and analysis | Provided technical advice and training to a law enforcement agency in relation to covert computer techniques used to identify internet based paedophiles. In addition, also developed a software tool that was subsequently used by the majority of law enforcement agencies in Australia and which received a Queensland award for innovation. | |
| Law enforcement | Capture and analysis | Engaged to provide forensic technology assistance to the NSW Police in relation to the investigation of a homicide. | |
| NGO | Capture and analysis | Provided forensic technology assistance in respect of the recovery and analysis of electronic evidence to support an investigation into unlawful and inappropriate activity by a number of staff at a Brisbane based Non Government Organisation. | |
| Regulatory | Capture and analysis | Assisted the Australian Securities and Investments Commission with the execution numerous search warrants in order to locate relevant electronic information. | |
| Manufacturing | Capture and analysis | Engaged to provide forensic technology assistance by the legal advisers of an Australian manufacturing company, including the execution of a number of Anton Pillar orders and undertaking a detailed examination of the recovered information. | |
| Regulatory | Capture and analysis | Managed the forensic acquisition, restoration, analysis, searching and provision of all electronic evidence related to a major Australian Securities and Investment Commission (ASIC) investigation where the volume of data was in excess of 30 Terabytes restored from over 700 backup tapes; | |
| Financial services | Capture and analysis | Provided on-going forensic technology assistance to a large financial services organisation in relation to numerous internal investigations where there was a heavy reliance on electronic evidence. This work comprised the preservation, capture, analysis and reporting of electronic evidence. | |
| Retail | Capture and analysis | Managed numerous electronic data analysis projects in the retail sector, which involved the design of specific analysis applications in order to identify suspected fraudulent transactions from within larger quantities of electronic data. | |
| Regulatory | Capture and analysis | Engaged to provide forensic technology by ASIC to execute various search warrants in conjunction with the Australian Federal Police. | |
| Energy and resources | Capture and analysis | Managed numerous electronic data analysis projects in the mining sector, which involved the design of specific analysis applications in order to identify suspected fraudulent transactions from within larger quantities of electronic data. | |
| Retail | Capture and analysis | Provided on-going forensic technology support to a large Australian based retailer in respect of numerous internal investigations which required data recovery, analysis and reporting of electronic evidence. | |
| Public sector | Capture and analysis | Provided forensic technology support as part of a large internal investigation for a Melbourne based University, detailing findings and recommendations by way of comprehensive statements and reports. | |
| Agriculture | Capture and analysis | Provided forensic technology support as part of the receivership of Evans and Tate Limited. | |
| Manufacturing | Capture and analysis | Provided forensic technology support as part of the Nylex receivership. | |
| Telecommunications | Capture and analysis | Provided forensic technology support as part of the receivership of Commander Communications. | |
| Telecommunications | Class action / Competition | Assisted the Regulator in quantifying charges levied and commissions withheld by a telecommunications retailer from its Franchisees in an alleged breach of the Trade Practices Act and the Franchising Code. | Independent expert witness |
| Information Technology | Class action / Competition | Engaged by the ACCC to quantify the value of underpaid Airtime commissions by a Telecommunications Reselling Franchisor to 63 of its Franchised stores. The work comprised compiling and analysising millions of individual transactions over a prolonged period of time using data analytic techniques. | Independent expert witness |
| Agriculture | Class action / Competition | Preparation of an independent expert report and the giving of evidence in relation to the collapse of a major listed managed investment scheme group operating in the agriculture sector. The issues addressed related to the intergrated operations of the group, whether it was experiencing financial difficulty and disclosures to the market. | Independent expert witness |
| Pharmaceuticals | Class action / multi-party litigation | Extracted sales data and constructed a complex financial model to estimate the potential value of claims against the pharmaceutical company by customers and other third parties following the largest product recall in Australia. The analysis was used by the acting directors to make critical decisions regarding the future of the company. | Consulting expert |
| Business services | Class action / multi-party litigation | Engaged by a New York law firm on behalf of the Defendant in a shareholder class action litigation. Reviewed financial records and other documents to assess the accuracy and timeliness of disclosures to the market regarding financial performance and earnings forecasts. | Consulting expert |
| Energy and resources | Class action / multi-party litigation | Project managed and subsequently led the forensic team acting as independent expert for a global energy and natural resources business, quantifying class action claims for property damage and consequential losses arising from the interruption of the gas supply to business and domestic users in Victoria following the Longford fire and explosion. | Independent expert witness |
| Retail | Class action / multi-party litigation / Regulatory enquiry | Engaged as consulting experts by a global packaging business defending multiple customer and class action claims in respect of allegations of price fixing including the review and quantification of multiple loss and damage claims as well as the formulation of litigation strategies. | Consulting expert |
| Pharmaceuticals | Competition and price fixing / regulatory enquiry | Appointed by a legal firm to assist its client in conducting an investigation into allegations of anti-competitive pricing behaviour. The investigation included the identification, capture, restoration and targeted review of tens of thousands of documents, both electronic and hard-copy, the creation of a chronological time series of meetings and telephone calls held between relevant parties to the matter and the presentation of findings to the competition regulator. | Consulting expert |
| Energy and resources | Competition and price fixing / regulatory enquiry | Led the forensic team engaged to analyse product pricing records on behalf of a global energy and natural resources business following claims of anti-competitive pricing behaviour by the competition regulator. The work comprised the use of data mining software (ACL) to identify pricing behaviour patterns and overlay this information with timings of meetings and telephone conversations between alleged relevant parties. | Consulting expert |
| Energy and resources | Compliance review | Conducted an internet and email compliance audit on behalf of an international mining company. The results of the compliance review were reported to management and required the subsequent investigation of a number of employees. | |
| Financial services | Compliance review | Conducted investigations into the management of mortgage loan portfolios. | |
| Public sector | Compliance review | Undertook systems compliance reviews in the local and state government sectors, including assessment of compliance with regulatory requirements and identification of opportunities to enhance business systems. | |
| Public sector | Compliance review | Performed the fraud risk assessment component of a forensic audit to identify fraud and non-compliance within a Federal Government stimulus program. The engagement involved identifying and assessing potential fraud risks, analysing relevant data and reviewing claims to identify potentially inappropriate behaviour. | |
| Public sector | Conflict of interest | Appointed by the NSW government to undertake an investigation into allegations of corrupt behaviour in connection with the alleged preferential treatment of awarding contracts to suppliers. Reviewed financial records, interviewed employees and senior management, conducted corporate searches and captured electronic data. | |
| Consulting and Professional services | Conflict of interest | Managed, reviewed and provided documents to the SEC in the United States in relation to potential independence issues involving an international professional services firm that allegedly provided inappropriate services to its SEC registered clients. It was alleged that the services provided were prohibited under SEC rules and regulations. | |
| Public sector | Conflict of interest | Engaged to investigate allegations of misconduct and financial impropriety at an Australian University. The investigation considered alleged conflicts of interest, alleged misuse of the Universities intellectual property and alleged improper transactions between related parties. | |
| Information Technology | Conflict of interest | Led an investigation into allegations of conflicts of interest held by certain procurement employees of an international business services group with third party suppliers. | |
| Energy and resources | Conflict of interest | Investigation into alleged inappropriate behaviour and conflicts of interest by employees. It was alleged that several suppliers were companies in which several employees had direct interests. | Consulting expert |
| Telecommunications | Contractual dispute | Engaged by a law firm to critique an expert report which quantified the loss of profit allegedly suffered in relation to a breach of contract. The plaintiff was an agent that had been engaged by a major telecommunications company (the defendant) to promote the sale of certain services offered by the defendant until the contract was terminated. | Independent expert witness |
| Waste management | Contractual dispute | Engaged by the legal advisers of a waste management company to prepare an independent expert accountants report quantifying the loss and damage suffered by their client arising from the actions of a state owned corporation who allegedly prevented their client from building a materials recycling facility. | Independent expert witness |
| Business services | Contractual dispute | Engaged by the legal advisers of a building and construction company to quantify the loss and damage suffered by their client in tendering for two cleaning and maintenance contracts in the Sydney area. It was alleged that the tendering and contract award processes were not fair or equitable to all bidding parties. | Independent expert witness |
| Transport | Contractual dispute | Provided expert evidence in the Patrick and Toll closed arbitration involving financial claims of between $300 and $500 million (as quoted in the press). As publicly reported, the dispute centred on a contract under which Toll provided services to Pacific National Limited (PNL) in North Queensland. Patrick claimed that Toll benefited from the deal, which would create a $510 million revenue shortfall for PNL over 20 years. | Independent expert witness |
| Information Technology | Contractual dispute | Assisted with the assessment of damages in an IT dispute, in which the client was unsatisfied with the software implementation performed by a third party. Worked with an IT systems implementation expert to assess the claim based on the nature of the issues and likely costs involved with the implementation of a new system. | Independent expert witness |
| Transport | Contractual dispute | Instructed as an independent accounting expert on behalf of a NSW State Government owned transport organisation which was defending a claim for loss and damage made against it by a transport company for breach of contract. | Independent expert witness |
| Construction | Contractual dispute | Instructed by a legal firm to quantify the liquidated damages arising in a construction industry dispute surrounding the alleged late completion of project works. | Independent expert witness |
| Telecommunications | Contractual dispute | Instructed as an independent accounting expert on behalf of a listed telecommunications business to respond to a claim for loss and damage arising from an alleged breach of contract. | Independent expert witness |
| Construction | Contractual dispute | Prepared an expert report on the balance of loans secured over a number of development properties. A second registered mortgagee disputed the amount the first registered mortgagee had received on the loans in excess of an agreed upon priority amount. The work involved a review and analysis of principal, interest and other transactions involving the secured properties and seven loan accounts and a response to an opposing expert’s report | Independent expert witness |
| Financial services | Contractual dispute | Provided accounting advice to a financial institution on the potential breach of loan covenants. The client alleged that the payment of dividends had caused a customer to breach the level of profits required under a loan covenant. Expert advice was provided on the distribution of profits permitted under Australian Accounting Standards and the Corporations Law as well as an analysis of actual distributions; | Consulting expert |
| Business services | Contractual dispute | Quantified the economic loss on the early termination of a contract to provide lift maintenance services for the purposes of the preparation of an independent expert accountants report. | Independent expert witness |
| Public sector | Corruption | Undertook an investigation into suspicions of fraud, corruption and conflicts of interest involving falsification of property titles in Kingston, Jamaica. This assignment included the review of records, interviews with staff and informants and liaising with local police. | |
| Waste management | Corruption | Investigated allegations of corruption in the metal recycling industry, involving company management and site managers allegedly receiving kickbacks from suppliers, who were also potentially related parties, in return for overpayment for goods supplied. | |
| Energy and resources | Corruption | Appointed by a public utility to investigate protected disclosures alleging improper conduct involving a senior employee. The work involved the review of documentation and interviewing employees, related parties and members of the Board of Directors. | |
| Manufacturing | Corruption | Appointed by an international computer manufacturer to investigate the alleged breach of code of conduct policies in one of its businesses arising from allegations of the receipt of corrupt payments from an employee of a service provider. | |
| Retail | Corruption | Engaged to investigate allegations of corruption involving senior executives of a large listed Australian retailer, which identified inappropriate dealings with the company’s suppliers. Their employment was subsequently terminated. | |
| Manufacturing | Corruption | Conducted an investigation on behalf of a small listed company into related party transactions and assessment of their appropriateness in accordance with statutory requirements. | |
| Consulting and Professional services | Defamation | Quantified the losses suffered by a consultant pursuant to an allegation of defamation regarding an article published in a leading business magazine. | Independent expert witness |
| Automotive | Director breaches | Provided investigative forensic services to the Administrator of a public automotive parts company in relation to significant events leading up to its administration. Undertook a detailed analysis of documents including electronic records as well as interviewed senior management to determine if the Corporations Act had been breached and whether insider trading had occurred. | |
| Insurance | Director breaches | Provided investigative forensic services to the Liquidator of HIH Insurance Limited, including the review of electronic evidence as well as an analysis of events and timeframes leading up to the occurrence of significant transactions. | |
| Manufacturing | Director breaches | Led an investigation on behalf of a large German corporation into a director of an Australian subsidiary. The director was alleged to have breached his duties in relation to the keeping of proper books and records and to have made false or misleading claims for consulting and out of pocket expenses. Our report was provided to assist the client negotiate a termination of his employment. | |
| Energy and resources | Economic loss | Assisted in the preparation of an expert report calculating the economic loss suffered by a private electricity generation company in the Northern Territory. The government was found to have breached the Trade Practices Act and were to pay damages to the company. The quantification of loss involved a detailed analysis of the electricity generation business and electricity markets in Australia. | Independent expert witness |
| Financial services | Economic loss | Instructed by the legal department of a financial services organisation to respond to an expert accountants report quantifying the alleged losses suffered by a retail business following the withdrawal of funding arrangements by the organisation. | Independent expert witness |
| Printing | Economic loss | Quantified the alleged loss and damage suffered by eight printing and graphical reproduction franchises arising from a dispute regarding alleged negligent financial information contained in a prospectus which had induced the franchisees to enter into the franchise agreement. | Independent expert witness |
| Transport | Economic loss | Instructed as an independent accounting expert on behalf of an international freight forwarding business to respond to a claim for loss and damage made against it by a customer whose goods had been lost in transit. | Independent expert witness |
| Manufacturing | Economic loss | Prepared an expert report calculating the economic loss suffered by a swimming pool manufacturer resulting from the supply of a defective resin for use in the manufacturing process. The swimming pools suffered blistering and required replacement. The work included the quantification of loss based on three scenarios of expansion forecast by the business at the time of supply; | Independent expert witness |
| Pharmaceuticals | Economic loss | Assisted in the preparation of an independent expert report quantifying the alleged economic loss arising from the cessation in supply of products from a major pharmaceuticals supplier (in liquidation). The work involved the review and analysis of accounting and sales information, the production of a financial model estimating the financial loss based on a number of scenarios and a critique of the opposing expert’s report; | Independent expert witness |
| Manufacturing | Economic loss | Assisted a major publicly-listed Australian steel company quantify losses suffered following an alleged breach of a non-compete clause pursuant to the sale of a business. | Independent expert witness |
| Agriculture | Economic loss | Quantified the losses incurred by a winery pursuant to the tainting of several vintages by a third party service provider. | Independent expert witness |
| Manufacturing | Economic loss | Quantified the losses incurred by an air conditioning installer forced to re-install faulty air conditioning units. | Independent expert witness |
| Manufacturing | Economic loss | Critiqued losses claimed by an air conditioning distributor following a 'stop supply' by a manufacturer. | Consulting expert |
| Financial services | Economic Loss | Assisted a regulator with their representative action to quantify the losses suffered by investors (predominantly retirees) who borrowed significant amounts of funds via margin loans to invest into products offered by a financial services firm who subsequently lost their investments when the firm was placed into liquidation. | Independent expert witness |
| | Economic Loss | Engaged by a law firm to act as an independent expert on behalf of a major telecommunications provider. The company was defending a preference payment action exceeding $100 million. | Independent expert witness |
| Media and Entertainment | Economic Loss | Engaged by an events manager to defend a breach of contract claim in relation to major sporting events that were to be rolled out in Asia. The events manager terminated the agreement and the plaintiff had lodged a claim for damages. | Independent expert witness |
| Energy and resources | Economic Loss | Engaged to quantify the economic loss arising from the shutdown of a gas pipeline. | Independent expert witness |
| Manufacturing | Electronic discovery | Engaged by legal advisers to provide electronic discovery assistance in relation to a class action litigation including the production of data and the identification of relevant data. | |
| Telecommunications | Electronic discovery | Provided electronic discovery services to the Liquidator of One Tel. The assignment included both the capture of live data and the extraction of information from backup tapes. The data was searched and relevant information was provided to legal advisors. | |
| Legal | Electronic discovery | Managed numerous large electronic discovery matters which involved providing specialist support in scoping and identifying sources of electronic data, capturing, searching and filtering electronic data, processing data in accordance with agreed protocols and producing results compatible for use in recognised legal review applications. | |
| Public sector | Employee misconduct | Managed an investigation into allegations of employee misconduct at a Victorian primary school. | |
| Public sector | Employee misconduct | Assisted with the investigation on behalf of a State government department in relation to the department’s provision of services and assistance to a convicted child sex offender. The work involved establishing the factual circumstances of the assistance provided by the department, the relevant policies and procedures in place and whether such policies and procedures had been breached; | |
| Public sector | Employee misconduct | Led several investigations into allegations of misconduct against Principals and/or Business Managers of Victorian Secondary Schools. | |
| Financial services | Employee misconduct | Managed a team investigating an employee at an investment bank suspected of sending out unauthorised letters of representation on behalf of the bank. Coordinated the targeted review of electronic data in order to identify the scale of the issue so that the bank could contact the necessary third parties. | |
| Media and Entertainment | Employee misconduct | Engaged to investigate potential kickbacks that may have been made by the marketing team of a major Austraian media company to various advertising firms. | |
| Energy and resources | Employee misconduct | Engaged to review the relationship between our client and an IT supplier, with a view to establishing the appropriateness of transactions and conduct by our client's staff. | Consulting expert |