Technology does not create value; better decisions do

16 November 2026

Discussions about value creation in aged care often focus on acquisition, scale, artificial intelligence and digital transformation. These factors matter but they can distract from a more fundamental question: does the organisation have the information and management discipline to identify problems early and act decisively?

This question emerged clearly during our recent webinar, What Drives Value in Aged Care? Market Trends, M&A Insights and Executive Priorities. Whilst the panellists approached value from different perspectives, there was a common theme that technology and scale are enablers, not outcomes. Lasting value depends on operational capability, workforce quality and the ability to turn reliable information into timely action.
.

Complexity is testing management capability

Aged care providers are balancing workforce shortages, margin pressure, quality outcomes, technology investments, home care reform, and changing stakeholder expectations. Many providers have responded by investing in care platforms, medication and risk management tools, workforce systems, finance systems and reporting solutions.

Yet, even with sophisticated systems, some are still struggling to identify the sub-services like cleaning and garden maintenance experiencing deteriorating margin performance and why.  This is most important as organisation grow to achieve scale. The McGrathNicol 2026 Working Capital Report found that whilst 91% of health & aged care companies achieved revenue growth, only 41% improved gross margins, demonstrating that growth alone is not enough. Management needs viability of where performance is changing and what is driving it.

The constraint is often the ability to turn fragmented data into trusted, timely and actionable insights. This challenge becomes more pronounced as organisations grow.

“Scale can also create risk. If you grow at a fast pace without integrating systems, and you have inconsistency across homes and regions, that can add a great deal of complexity.” - Sam Winter, Chief Business Development Officer, Estia Health

Growth creates value only when systems, processes, management capability and accountability keep pace. Otherwise, scale can make emerging problems harder to identify and respond to.
.

Better decisions depend on reliable information

When reporting is inadequate, the instinct can be to look for another technology solution. In practice, effective reporting and analytics depend on core data foundations including:

  • controls over data entry;

  • practical training for frontline staff;

  • clear and documented processes;

  • defined ownership and accountability; and

  • integration between systems, supported by data quality controls.

These foundations attract less attention than artificial intelligence, but they determine whether technology investments produce useful outcomes.
.

Reliable information matters beyond day-to-day reporting

Reliable data and information give boards, investors, lenders and potential acquirers greater confidence that management understands performance and has planned a response for when conditions change. Without it, stakeholders may raise questions about governance and the management team’s ability to execute.

"Compliance is just the licence to operate. It’s the bare minimum, and it’s really about quality care.” - Thomas Griffiths, General Manager, Strategy, BaptistCare NSW, ACT and WA

. 

Technology still depends on people

The panel was equally clear that systems cannot compensate for gaps in workforce capability. If people do not trust the information, understand its purpose, or know what action is expected, technology will not deliver efficiencies.

“Investing in workforce … is critical for any business in aged care to be successful.” - Lisa Pendlebury, General Manager, Corporate Development, Regis Aged Care

Technology requires operational ownership, practical training and clear accountability, and direct links to the decisions and the care, workforce and financial outcomes being pursued.
. 

The real test

Technology alone will not create value. The better test is whether management can answer a few fundamental questions with confidence:

  • Where is operational, financial, workforce or quality performance deteriorating?

  • Do we understand what is driving that change?

  • Is the information reliable enough to make a decision?

  • Is responsibility for action clear?

  • Can we determine whether that action improved the outcome?

If those questions are difficult to answer consistently, the issue may not be a lack of technology but rather the information, reporting, processes and accountability surrounding it.

McGrathNicol works with aged care organisations to understand these issues, identify where visibility or control is breaking down, and translate operational and financial information into practical actions that support better performance and decision making.