Unlisted asset valuations — Strengthening confidence in superannuation fund investment values
11 November 2026
:quality(80))
:quality(80))
Unlisted assets such as private equity, private credit, property, and infrastructure are significant and growing components of many superannuation fund portfolios. As regulatory scrutiny increases, superannuation trustees require valuations that are current and capable of withstanding challenge.
Without readily observable market prices, the values of unlisted assets depend on forecasts, assumptions, valuation methodologies, and information supplied by investment managers or portfolio companies. This means the quality of the valuation process is critical to unit pricing, performance reporting, investment decisions, and member outcomes.
At 30 June 2024, APRA-regulated superannuation entities held approximately A$500 billion in unlisted assets. APRA’s December 2024 review into how superannuation trustees govern unlisted asset valuation and liquidity risk management found that 12 of the 23 RSE licensees examined required material improvement in valuation governance, liquidity risk management, or both. ASIC’s surveillance of superannuation fund financial reports has also heightened scrutiny of the evidence supporting unlisted investment values and the audit work performed over them. For trustees, the practical question is whether reported values remain reasonable at the measurement date and whether the supporting analysis is robust enough for boards, auditors, regulators, and members.
A valuation undertaken independently of the investment decision-making process provides a clear basis for testing the methodology, key assumptions, and reliance placed on manager-supplied information.
Courtney Roe, Partner
Scrutiny is moving from policy to valuation evidence
SPS 530 Investment Governance has required RSE licensees to maintain a valuation governance framework since January 2023. APRA’s subsequent reviews indicate that having a policy is only the starting point. Trustees must be able to demonstrate how values were determined, when they were reassessed, and how key assumptions and judgements were challenged.
APRA’s 2023 review of superannuation fund investments in Canva identified inadequate interim revaluation triggers, gaps in information provided to boards, and limitations in board capability. A further review in 2024 identified weaknesses across valuation frequency and triggers, controls, conflicts management, board oversight, and fair value reporting.
APRA’s proposed September 2026 amendments to SPS 530 would move several expectations into the binding prudential standard and introduce additional investment governance safeguards. Although the reforms remain subject to consultation, they signal the regulator’s continued focus on valuation governance, and superannuation funds should expect closer examination of the analysis, controls, and evidence supporting their unlisted asset values.
.
Where valuation risk arises for superannuation funds
Values can become stale between formal valuation dates
Market movements, asset-specific developments, refinancing events, or changes in forecast performance may occur before the next scheduled valuation. If these developments are not reflected in valuation outcomes, members entering, exiting, or switching an investment option may transact at a value that no longer reflects current conditions.
Manager-prepared valuations require informed challenge
Investment managers and portfolio companies often hold more detailed information about an asset. Their analysis is an important input, but trustees still need to understand the methodology, test significant assumptions, and assess whether the information reflects conditions at the valuation date. This is particularly important where performance reporting, remuneration, or transaction activity may affect the valuation context.
Valuation uncertainty extends beyond financial reporting
Unlisted asset values inform unit prices, reported investment returns, strategic asset allocation, and liquidity decisions. Valuation analysis should identify key sensitivities and ranges, rather than presenting only a single point estimate, so decision-makers can understand how changes in material assumptions may affect the fund and its members.
.
When should a superannuation fund seek an independent valuation
Periodic portfolio review - to assess the reasonableness and consistency of valuations across the fund’s material unlisted asset holdings.
Material market or asset-specific change - when movements in listed comparables, interest rates, operating performance, financing, or transaction evidence may indicate that a carrying value should be reconsidered.
To support a specific transaction - such as an acquisition, disposal, rollover or internal transfer.
Manager-prepared valuation review - when the trustee requires deeper testing of the methodology, forecasts, discount rates, multiples, or other significant inputs.
To withstand regulatory, board, or investor scrutiny - when a clearly documented independent valuation is required to support unit pricing, financial reporting, or audit support.
.
What a defensible valuation should demonstrate
A valuation should do more than produce a number. It should provide transparent, reproducible analysis that enables the trustee to understand the drivers of value, the sources of uncertainty, and the effect of alternative assumptions. A reliable valuation should be evident from:
A clearly defined valuation date, purpose, basis of value, and scope of work.
Methodologies appropriate to the asset.
The use of relevant market evidence where available, such as comparable company and transaction data, to inform key assumptions or cross check conclusions, with explanations for material differences.
Consideration of asset-specific rights, restrictions, illiquidity, and other features relevant to the interest held by the fund.
Sensitivity analysis to understand the impact of key inputs on valuation conclusions
Documentation of key assumptions, judgements made and the evidence supporting the concluded value.
For superannuation funds, confidence in an unlisted asset value depends not only on the methodology applied, but also on the quality of the evidence, the rigour of the analysis, and a defensible conclusion.
.
How McGrathNicol supports superannuation funds
McGrathNicol provides independent valuation advice which can support superannuation funds across unlisted private equity, private credit, and other complex investments. Our work can be tailored to the fund’s requirements and may involve valuing an asset or investment interest, reviewing a manager-prepared valuation, testing selected assumptions, or assessing a portfolio of holdings using a risk-based approach.